How long do you allow someone to develop into a premier leader, in this case, a premier college football coach?When Lou Holtz accepted the ND job in 1986 he had 16 years of head coaching experience. We were fortunate enough to get a seasoned ball coach. His ND record: 100-32-2 was impressive.
Bob Davie was known as a defensive specialist but had no head coaching experience. His ND record: 35-25.
Ty Willingham was an assistant at several D-1 programs before coaching Stanford for seven seasons prior to taking the ND job. He led the Cardinal to a 44–36–1 record as head coach. His ND record: 35-25; much like his previous record.
Charlie Weis had reached the pinnacle of NFL success as an assistant coach with the Superbowl Champion New England Patriots, but he was never a college football head coach. His ND record: 35-26.
Was Charlie a bad hire? Look at the previous coaches, Davie and Willingham, and the struggles they had. Is it reasonable to think it would take only a few years to rebuild a badly beaten-down football program? Did they give him ample time to develop into a great college coach or did they think his Super Bowl rings were a good enough resume? Or was Charlie's development not taken into consideration. It will take a grrrrrreat! coach and some serious soul searching & personnel shifting within the UND administration to bring this program back to prominence. I don't think a return to glory is going to happen within five years, if at all.
I will always be an Irish fan, I just don't expect a national championship any time soon. And boy, do I hope I am wrong.


